When to Repair or Replace Your Garage Door: A Helpful Guide

March 26, 2023

Homeowners know the value of having a garage, especially in inclement weather. Not having to warm up your vehicle or sweep snow off the windshield is a bonus to protecting your vehicle. Yet, a garage is only as good as your garage door.


When the garage door malfunctions or is damaged, it poses significant safety risks and exposes your home to water, snow, and even theft. Yet, how do you know when to repair the garage door rather than replace it? This guide will help you explore the ins and outs of
garage door solutions. 


Signs That Your Garage Door Needs Repairing


Issues with your garage door may start small, but they can quickly become glaring. The following signs are a good indication that you need a garage door repair:


  • Noisy, squealing sounds during its operation
  • The door doesn’t open or close fully
  • Slow to open or close
  • Loose or broken wires, springs, rollers
  • The garage door opener is malfunctioning
  • The door becomes unbalanced, leaving a gap on one side when closed
  • The door jerks or shutters in motion
  • The garage door is coming off the track


The Cost of Repairing a Garage Door


Repairing your garage door will involve hourly labour and part costs. It will also depend on the type of garage door, its size, and its age. 


So, one must consider where the issue stems from and how involved the repair will be. Here are some rough estimates on repairing the different garage door components:


  • Track rollers/wheels average between $90-200
  • Door cables average between $100-400
  • Door pulley repair averages between $85-160
  • Chain and belt-drive motor replacement averages between $275-750
  • Small holes, dents, and cracks in door panels range from $100-200 each
  • Garage door opener replacement ranges from $150-500 plus labour


The Cost of Replacing a Garage Door


All-out garage door replacement costs vary depending on style, size, and installation complexity. For example, standard single garage doors range between $1500-2000, whereas a double garage door averages around $2300-3500.


Yet these prices may not reflect certain styles or materials. Additionally, consider future maintenance costs that come with particular garage door types, such as:


  • Steel
  • Aluminum
  • Wood
  • Fibreglass
  • Flushmount


Factors to Consider When Deciding Whether to Repair or Replace Your Garage Door


Knowing whether to repair or replace your garage door all boils down to a few significant factors. Consider the following:


  1. The door’s age - if the door is under five years old, a repair is more feasible. If the door is over 15, a replacement will likely be a better choice.
  2. The door’s style - if the door is malfunctioning or damaged, now might be the perfect opportunity to upgrade your home’s aesthetic.
  3. Energy efficiency - older garage doors aren’t as well insulated, and replacement can help lower your energy bills.
  4. Cost - if the repair cost is likely higher, then replacement is a better option.
  5. Safety - if a repair is a temporary fix to ongoing issues, then the risk of damaging your vehicle or injury to you or your family isn’t worth waiting to replace your garage door.


How to Find a Reliable Garage Door Repair or Replacement Service


Professional garage door services are well worth the money when you consider that they have the right tools and knowledge to do the job quickly and efficiently. Ultimately, they save you time and money, repair and install your garage door safely, and can offer warranties on their work and products. You also know you’ve found the right providers when their customers provide rave reviews.


One such company is
Maple Overhead Garage Doors Inc. in Concord, ON. They offer top-quality garage doors in all the latest materials and styles, paired with spectacular service.


Invest in your garage door today! Book your quote
online or call 905-738-9231 now!

Two white garage doors with wreaths, snow on the driveway.
December 3, 2025
What decorations are safe for steel, wood, and fiberglass doors? Get tips to avoid scratches and keep warranties intact in Toronto, Richmond Hill, and Markham.
White overhead garage door with horizontal gray reinforcement bars.
November 19, 2025
Entertain in comfort this Thanksgiving. Learn how insulated, quiet doors reduce drafts and noise for guests in Toronto, Brampton, Oakville, and Burlington.
Modern home exterior with black garage door, concrete facade, and brick building beside.
November 5, 2025
Winterize your garage door with GTA experts. Prevent freezing, stop drafts, and quiet noise for safer holidays in Toronto, Mississauga, Vaughan, and beyond.
A modern house with a large driveway in front of it
October 21, 2025
See how flushmount garage doors offer a seamless, modern upgrade for your residential property.
A house with a large garage and a blue door
October 7, 2025
Get expert tips on choosing the right installation service and why experience matters for lasting results.
A large brick house with a gray garage door
September 16, 2025
Discover why steel garage doors offer durability, security, and style for homes in the GTA.
A white house with a large glass garage door.
September 2, 2025
Find out why fullview aluminum garage doors are perfect for durability and style as colder months approach.
A wooden garage door is on the side of a stone building.
August 19, 2025
Learn how custom wooden garage doors can transform the look and value of your Toronto home.
A large white garage door is sitting in front of a house.
August 5, 2025
Explore the benefits of fiberglass garage doors for security and style in Ontario neighborhoods.
A modern garage door with a lot of windows on the side of a house.
July 18, 2025
Upgrade your garage with the latest door openers featuring smart technology for enhanced security and convenience, brought to you by Maple Overhead Garage Doors.